shake-shack Secret Menu

Just when you thought Shake Shack couldn’t get even better, they release the secret menu. This hidden list of items is growing, and we are doing our best to keep up.

Please comment below if you are a Shake Shack insider and know about other secret menu items we can add to this list. Enjoy!


Peanut Butter & Bacon ShackBurger

Yes, you read that correctly. They had this on the actual menu for one weekend and it sold like (pea)nuts. But, due to allergy concerns, they took it off the standard menu, but is available on the secret menu.
Ask them for peanut sauce on the side of your bacon Shackburger and you will drizzle that amazing sauce all over your bacon and patty.

WARNING: this may change your life and if you are a peanut butter fan, then you need to drive to your nearest Shake Shack now.

The Smoke Shack Quad Burger

If I could marry a burger, I would marry this quad-monster.

So much cheese and so much flavor. So much amazing-ness bursting in my mouth.
Just ask for this beast by name and you shall be served. This is not for the kind at heart.

If you’re on a diet, you might want to steer clear of this 2k+ calorie packer. Otherwise, eat on. It’s so worth it.

Shackburger with pickles

Your favorite Shake Shackburger just got a whole lot beast-ier (that’s a word, right?). Add some crunchy pickle madness to the already mad Shackburger for added nirvana.
You will thank me later for this one. If you love pickles, this is a MUST have on your next burger.

Just ask for pickles on your burger when ordering and you should have no problem. Heck, even ask for extra pickles on the side if you’re feeling it.

Shackburger with Onions

Sorry for teasing you all with the pickles. You can even add onions into the mix for an added crunchy experience. Their onions seem to always be JUST right and I love the added kick.
Of course, if you have a hot date later on, don’t have too many onions, you onion-breath demon! Let’s be real, screw the date – add the onions.

Just ask for onions when ordering and your wish is the Shackmaster’s command.

Shakeburger Cheese Dog Hotdog

The photo is not worth a thousand bites, because that’s what you’ll want to do to this cheesy goodness when it’s in your hands.
They split the freaking hotdog and smother hot, delicious cheese all over it.

Just ask for a Cheese Dog and they should know what you mean. If not, give the cashier a wink and tell her you want hot cheese smothered all over your hot dog. (don’t really do this).

Shack-Cago Burger

You might need to put this one together yourself, but the flavors make it super worth it.

Order the Chicago style hotdog, and transfer the special relish, onion, cucumber, pickle, tomato, mustard, celery salt and peppers to your burger for a masterpiece of flavors.

You’re left with an amazing Chicago style burger and a hot dog to enjoy. Remember, you can always add cheese to that hotdog.

Grilled Cheese Sandwich (add bacon too)

The bread – the cheese – the optional bacon. OMG. So delicious.

You can order this one by name and you can have the bacon on the side. You can even have a side of that peanut sauce for a peanut butter grilled cheese with bacon.





Extra Shack Sauce

We agree with you, we can never have enough Shack sauce. Just ask for some extra sauce and you’ll get it. If they charge you, it shouldn’t be more than 50 cents.
Most of the time, if you ask when picking up your order, they’ll hand you one for free, unless you need like 5 sauces like me. One for the road, please!

The Infamous “Shandy”

A hybrid of beer and lemonade. I know – it sounds disgusting. But, please trust me: it’s freaking delicious.
It’s only part beer and it is just a burst of flavors mixing in your mouth. It serves up a really refreshing experience.
Just ask for it and most location should already know what you’re talking about. Otherwise, you can ask for some beer in your lemonade. That should do it.

“Chili” Pepper Cheese Fries

This one is a crowd favorite. The chili peppers come chopped up and tossed in with cheese over the fresh-cut fries.

Just ask nicely, and they will be more than happy to serve you up this delicious side.

Protein Style (Bun-less) Any Burger

Taking a page right out of In-N-Out’s secret menu, any burger can be made “protein style” with no buns and lettuce wrapped instead.
All you carb counters rejoice!

Just ask for it protein style or without the buns and they will gladly take care of it for you.

Shake Shack Style Ice Cream Sandwich

We’re cheating just a little on this one, but it’s so goooood.
Ask for toasted buns on the side of your chosen ice cream.

Then, put that ice cream right smack dab in between those toasty buns and enjoy.

You will not regret this.

Date Modified - 06/14/2024